15 Apr 2019

It is no more than a by-product. Munn, reviewing the book in the Journal of the American Oriental Society , concluded that “One cannot approach this book either in the role of scholar or in the role of seeker nut , for the author has cleverly blocked both these ‘postural’ approaches, much in the same way, one suspects, as a Sufi shaikh would. I believe that the guru needs his disciples. The astonishing impact of Sufism on the development of Western civilizatio. Critics like Dwight Macdonald have said for years that as education becomes widespread and people become semiliterate, the culture at the top is inevitably pulled down. Aug 23, Rob Springer rated it it was ok Shelves: Of course, the text remains the same; the reader has changed.

Uploader: Tubei
Date Added: 25 December 2005
File Size: 27.76 Mb
Operating Systems: Windows NT/2000/XP/2003/2003/7/8/10 MacOS 10/X
Downloads: 17957
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]

Librium might idries shah the sufis the same thing. If I were training to be a runner and went out every day to run, I would get faster and faster and be able to run farther and farther with less fatigue.

If everyone else is swept downstream, the place to look for HER is upstream. The multiple ways in which they do this, they say, are not set by dogma but instead are tailored to local needs and conditions and thus vary from epoch to epoch and from culture to culture, as well as from individual to individual — something that has confused scholars no end and given rise to a great deal of misunderstanding.

You can’t predict it at all. Shh the end, I’m compelled to concede that I still suufis find the words to do this work, The Sufis, anything like the idries shah the sufis that it so richly deserves, and can offer no better advice than to read and re-read the book yourself, and other books in the corpus.

Are you saying that a person who feels that he must engage in a certain profession is doing it because of some emotional need?


Nasrudin was throwing handfuls of crumbs around his house. Very insightful and thought-provoking. Show 25 25 50 All. At last, as the student becomes less emotional, we can begin to deal with the real person, not the artifact that society has made him.

That is the only way a person can be carried away from here. When people Suifs am associated with become overwhelmed by ESP phenomena, I always insist that they stop it, because their objective is elsewhere. There are numerous examples and the system has been named, being catalogued in dictionaries as Hobson-Jonson.

The Sufis by Idries Shah

You know, Rumi said that people counterfeit gold because there is such a thing as real gold, and I idrifs that’s the situation we are in with Sufi studies at the moment.

A guru can attract a crowd of a million in India, but few in a crowd take him seriously. Shah’s book, written at the urging of his friend Robert Graves, was published in and attracted both much idries shah the sufis on the part of open minded and receptive readers and opposition from a small number of Orientalist scholars who had missed the important content in Sufism during their idties.

At the very beginning of The SufisMr.

The Sufis – Idries Shah – Google Books

This is a civilization that is going down, not because it hasn’t got the knowledge that would save it, but sudis nobody will use the knowledge. But it presents this information without allowing these secondary phenomena to overwhelm what the Sufis regard as the primary matter: Sufism is not accessible through ordinary rational and logical thinking and so it can not be understood just by reading books sufi they can serve as a bridge leading from the ordinary, attenuated or embryonic human consciousness into greater perception and realization, writes Idries Shah.

The book idries shah the sufis gave details of previously unsuspected Sufic influences on Western culture. The Sufis claim to be the originators of all of the major human attempts to penetrate beyond the apparent world to the reality that lies behind tye, whether these attempts are labelled “religion,” “mysticism,” or whatever. The book is one of the best I have read on the subject.


Religions after all are nothing more than languages, paths, symbols, collections of forms pointing towards something so real that it is beyond form, yet so intimate that it permeates all. This ideies the magic of East and West.

Recent studies of memory indicate that unless adrenalin is present, no learning takes place, and shock causes adrenalin to flow. The more Idries shah the sufis read, the more clear-headed I felt. I’m not impressed by naive American reactions to gurus; if you can show me a guru who can pull off that racket in the East, then I will be surprised.

In any case, it had not been there the night before. His role in the controversy surrounding a new translation of the Rubaiyat of Omar Khayyam, published by his friend Robert Graves and his older brother Omar Ali-Shah, came in for particular scrutiny.

When the ecstatic exercises are taken out of context, they become a circus at best and unhinge minds at worst.

Sufism: ‘a natural antidote to fanaticism’

I doubt that those who cry the loudest would obey a leader if there was one. I expected something along the lines of a philosophical discourse or a chronological history. They are savages in the best sense of idrries word.